Student Film Reviews

Film reviews from theaters, couches, and film festivals

Home | All Reviews | Festival Courses | Film and Media Studies | SBCC | | Log in

1. Josh Jenkins 02.10.09 / 12pm

   Yeah, this is one of my favorite movies. It is brilliantly written, directed, and acted. The true genius of the story lies with the author of the book, Chuck Palahniuk, however, the film captures that genius beautifully. I especially like how the plot of the movie reveals the final twist. (I’m not going to say what it is, so as not to ruin it for anyone who hasn’t seen it.) The clues that are given throughout the movie are very fun to try and find after seeing it for the first time. For instance, you never, in the entire movie, hear the real name of Edward Norton’s character. We only hear the fake names that he gives at the therapy sessions, and then the “other” name that we find out about later in the movie.
   Again, one of my favorite movies. Funny, interesting, thought-provoking, and just a pleasure to watch.
2. Chelsea Lucas 02.23.09 / 3pm

   I have watched this movie three times and each time I am still as interested as the first time I watched it. This movie is so well written that it makes you have to think about the true meaning and implications going on in the film. This is one of the more thought provoking films I have watched. I agree that there were many implications of the twist early on and throughout the movie. It took me two times watching this movie to fully understand what was going on. Once I figured out that Brad Pitt (Tyler Durdan) and Edward Norton’s character was the same character it reminded me a lot of the novel “Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde”. I find it interesting that this so called “Fight Club” turned into something that could be considered a cult. Overall this movie is very well written and a very thought provoking film.
3. Daniel Martony 03.08.09 / 6pm

   I absolutely loved this movie. The story line is so interesting, I have watched it probably 5 times and everytime I watch it, I notice different facts and pick up more and more information about the storyline.The way this film was written was remarkable and it had so many great twists and turns, the first time when I found out about the two main charcters being one man, it was very shocking and eye opening to me. Then in looking back and thinking it through it made complete sense to me and made me love this film even more, and it just got better and better as the film went on. I would reccomment it for all film watchers.
4. Robert Matz 03.17.09 / 8am

   This movie is one of a kind. Fincher hits it out of the park in so many ways. It is the simple things that make this action packed film so great, such as the fact that Norton’s character’s name is never truly revealed throughout the entire film. He has many pseudonyms, but it is a symbol of who he really is, which no one really knows. One of he main attractions for the film is the disposition of the settings and his use of color contrast to separate the normal world which Norton rejects and the underground world in which he lives in. The message for the fight for the common man is clearly the objective. It portrays a struggle between the hard working citizen such as a construction worker and how they make everyones lives easier but are under appreciated and unnoticed. This film is truly remarkable in every sense and is a treat to watch for any avid film watcher.
5. Ignacio Elias 03.18.09 / 9am

   Fight Club is a movie that is placed in it’s own category. Watching the movie for the first time was like trying a new type of food. I didn’t know what to expect and I didn’t know whether i was going to like it or not. Well I ended up enjoying this movie very much. The movie is filled with many twists and makes the audience think twice about what they think is going to happen next. The fight scenes are probably the best I have ever seen in a movie. Every fight is made to look so real and you feel the pain the other person is receiving in the battle. I love how the movie twist at the very end. I don’t think anybody that viewed this movie expected an ending like that one. Great movie!
6. Scott Percival 03.18.09 / 12pm

   Fight club is a movie that i have seen over and over again because it is so remarkable well written. This film grabs the intention of the viewer and is always making you think and appreciated what is happening in the film. I didn’t know that this film was actually based on novel and I’m going to be looking into this. The twist is this movie is so extreme when you find out that Brad Pit and Edward Norton’s character was the same characters and how he is living and dealing with a “new level” of insomnia. The fight scenes were my favorite part in the film because they really connected you to the character that the film was trying to pa tray. Overall i believe this film is a one of kind adventure that comes with great acting and achieved an excellent story with a twist at the end that could not be matched in another movie. An Awesome movie!!
7. Stephanie Kuhlman 03.19.09 / 5pm

   “Fight Club” is just one of those movies that you can watch over and over again and still be completely interested in it. The storyline is absolutely fascinating. Edward Norton plays my favorite character in this movie as insomniac who is tired of his life. His character intrigued me so much. I love that he went to the support groups and finally found a peace within himself which eventually led him to being able to sleep again. Once the fights started and Brad Pitt was brought into the picture the movie got only more and more interesting. Turning fighting into a therapy session was ingenious and then more ingenious when the club turned into a cult. The love character, Marla, was perfect. It made the twist at the end of the movie all the greater. The actors portrayed their characters very well. Norton fit his character to a “T” and Pitt played the “hard-ass” quite nicely. Helena Bonham Carter who played Marla, gave her character that rawness that you can’t miss. She was very creepy in the movie but then again at the same time she wanted what every woman wants, love. I absolutely love this movie and will watch it many, many times more.
8. Alexandria Roland 03.20.09 / 7am

   Having read Fight Club and actually all of Chuck Palahniuk’s novels I was very pleasantly surprised. I absolutely LOVED this movie. It holds true to the majority of the book, often quoting it word for word. There is a slightly different ending, but I am glad for that, because the book ending probably would have been a let down for such an epic movie. It was fun watching the rest of the movie before the twist and seeing all the foreshadowing and subtle hints to the twist. I like how the narrator was portrayed by Edward Norton and how Tyler Durden was made to seem completely crazy by Brad Pitt. Great acting, great directing, great story, and great editing. The movie overall was just fantastic.
9. Sean Edwards 03.20.09 / 3pm

   This was a great film. The best type of film is one that keeps you guessing and wondering what will happen next, or trying to make sense of why things are going happen. I have watched Fight Club four times and I love it more each time. I am always looking at every detail through out to see exactly when the hints start to drop. They give you most of the answers at the end of the movie, but there are so many little lines, actions etc through out the entire film that mean something different to you after you know the final outcome. The storyline and the acting are both top quality.
10. Sam Hochwald 03.20.09 / 9pm

    Fight Club is one of those great movies that you never mind watching again. The film is so complex, fast paced and interesting that it fascinates me no matter how many times I watch it. I think the film is definitely a masterpiece, full of lessons and ideals that we often miss in everyday life. Despite the darkness of the film, it makes the dirty, ugly, unkept lives of its two main characters seem beautifully simple, free and satisfying. The film points out the mental conditioning we face and shows the superficiality of pop culture. I thought that the actors in this film did a good job, and the directing of David Fincher is really outstanding. Fight Club is definitely on the short list of must see movies of the last decade.
11. KyeongSeok Um 03.20.09 / 9pm

    This film is the kind of movie that I had to watch over and over to understand it. I could understand just an idea that ‘I’ am only one who can find my personal freedom. In this film, the main character dreams ‘change’ and ‘freedom’, so he makes another version of himself in his unconsciousness. He enjoys the ‘freedoms’, but finally he recognizes that when ‘personal freedom’ and the ‘society system’ that are opposites of each other exist in the same place, there will be tragedy. This film makes me look back on this society that I’m in and realize how much my eagerness for freedom was hostile to this society. It was a complicated but good film.
12. Brian Gregory 03.22.09 / 7pm

    This movie just might be one of the greatest movies of all-time. It’s action packed and suspenseful as well. I was always wanting to know what would happen next in the crazy life of Tyler Durden. The most interesting part for me was trying to get into the head of someone who is literally pyscho! I loved the crazy rules the “Fight Club” would come up with, and at the beginning I really thought Norton and Pitt’s characters lived two different lives, but at the end of the film it sends you for a loop as you find out its really one person.
13. Emily Teter 04.14.09 / 8pm

    The first time I saw this movie, I watched it three times in a month and every time I thought it got more interesting. I have not seen it since then, but yet the movie sticks in my mind and I can almost recall the whole film scene by scene. I was absolutely fascinated by the plot, storyline, characters, and unique editing, but what gave me a greater appreciation for the film was seeing director David Fincher talk about it at the Santa Barbara International Film Festival this year. Hearing about his creative perspective and the process of making this film gave it such depth and made my love for Fight Club even deeper.
14. Hunter Pendleton 05.17.09 / 10pm

    Fight Club is by far one of the most captivating and original movies I have ever seen. From the action packed scenes to the twisted confusing storyline, you are driven deeper and deeper into this masterpiece of a film. As I have seen this film numerous times, nevertheless I am intrigued by the way the film captures the viewers attention. It is the intentions that instead of merely giving us all of the information to take in at once or in segments, the storyline conveniently indulges you to constructively think for yourself and guessing, as if “what is happening”. Along the way leaving bits and peaces for you to put together or soon to find out, that ties the story together. One of my favorite aspects of this film is that it is narrated by the “disoriented” Edward Norton. Nearly the entire film, this fascinating aspect that almost allows you to get right inside the character’s mind. From the minute you start watching till the very end, their is never a dull moment. Between the characters deranged outlook on life and the interesting but weird personalities, to the illuminating perspective of the characters insanity the film gives you a thrilling ride, leaving you in awe. Along those lines I would definitely consider this film to be an artistic and wildly beautiful film through the Directing, acting perspective, dialogue, cinematography, and last but definitely not least, the writer of the brilliant novel Fight Club and many great others, Chuck Palahniuk.
15. Jamie Netznik 06.23.09 / 9am

    Fight Club is a film that had a large following because it was very different at the time. I cannot think of another movie in history, that combined the standard action fighting “man movie” elements, with the underlying juxtaposition of the human mind. Normally movies with that psychological element, are just that. This movie attracted not only those who were into intellectual movies, but your average boy (or girl) who enjoyed a good fight scene. I thought that the film was done in an exquisite way, from the lighting throughout the film which helped set the tone, to the art done throughout the scene. One of the most memorable moments of the movie, was the end scene where the buildings are crumbling. That destructive moment was juxtaposed with a song being played by the Pixies. That was a very memorable and strong moment in Fight Club.
16. Erik Shafer 07.03.09 / 3pm

    David Fincher’s “Fight Club,” 1999, is a very moving and thought provoking drama. It shows very strong character development and very intense realization upon the finish of the movie. I will not reveal any major plot information, but in the ending scenes, Edward Norton’s character solves the internal struggles he had been dealing with throughout the course of the movie. I’ve seen this film many times, and every time it is a joy to search for hidden innuendo and dialogue about his problem in which I’ve missed previously. I think that the synergy between Brad Pitt’s character and Edward Norton was astounding. I enjoyed every moment of this film.
17. Brian Powers 07.10.09 / 4pm

    Fight Club without a doubt was one of the most entertaning movies I have ever wtached. The plot is extremely well written and the movies followed it to perfection. Also the affects of the fight scenes were amazing. To be able to creat fights and injuries that looked so real was a real sight to watch. Fight Club was an action movies, but also was entertaining for anyone. It was not simply aimed for men to view as anyone could get cuaght up in the crazy story line of the movie. You get so cauhgt up in the movie you even need to ask yourself many times what is really going on. The directors did a great job at making it not just a male action movie.
18. Dylan Roberg 07.17.09 / 10pm

    Fight club is one of the greatest psycho-thriller ever made. Everything from the direction, plot, characters, to the cast is in perfect harmony with the message the film attempts to convey. The psychological perspective on the result of living a corporate, regimented life like that of the narrator lead to the films overall message of socio-political anarchy. The directors of the movie were able to achieve a perfect balance between plot movements, fight sequences, narration, and overall plot sequence. There is not a single part of the movie that causes one to feel as if a scene is dragging on, or that they wish the scene could have gone on longer. The movie is simply perfection.
19. Haley Omanson 10.27.09 / 2pm

    This is defiantly one of my favorite movies of all time. I have not come across anyone who did not like the movie so far. This movie brilliantly conveyed a very dark theme to it. In which the dark theme was shown was through the setting and constant lighting used throughout the lighting. In most scenes the lighting seemed to bring a dismal ominous state of mind to it. When the main character was narrating the story his voice always stayed the same tone through out his dialogue. The tone was never too loud, or soft enough for a whisper. This makes the audience feel the constant battle he was having with himself. This was another factor as to why the movie portrayed such a dark theme. The theme of the film fight club is what makes it so unique, and a popular favorite. With all of these elements and the surprise twist at the end when it is revealed that he in fact is schizophrenic makes the movie unforgettable. It is a film that is hard to beat and sends a very individual message to the audience that makes them thinking about the plot longer after the film is finished.
20. Meghan Kirkland 05.03.10 / 6pm

    FIGHT CLUB IS MY ABSOLUTE FAVORITE MOVIE! I can literally quote you lines from this film. This is one of the rare instances where “Fight Club” the film outshines “Fight Club” the book. Now don’t get me wrong I enjoyed the book, and have read every novel Chuck Palahniuk has written, but screenwriter Jim Uhls and director David Fincher have blown the roof off the building with their screen version. Most could mistake this film as being too dark or violent if they have never seen it before. However once you watch “Fight Club” it is easy to get mesmerized by the shifting story. In addition don’t be surprised if you find yourself laughing at the utter absurdity of the grim situations. They are out right hilarious! This film was made over ten years ago but has held up so well that you might think it was made yesterday. Edward Norton is on fire in this movie, and he believably pulls off playing the duel roles of his personality. Brad Pitt as Tyler Durden is so slick and cool, that he would make any woman buy 100 bars of his fatty pink soap! And Helena Bonham Carter as Marla, is both strangely sexy and terribly intriguing. I cannot say enough great things about this film because it is that good. Do yourself a favor and buy the recently released special edition Blu-Ray disc of “Fight Club” and spread a little mayhem for Tyler’s sake…
21. Michael Levy 07.21.11 / 9pm

    This is simply one of the greatest and most original and one of kind movies ever made. The plot makes you wondering the whole movie and the twists leave you in shock and with chills down your spine. I love how the movie was shot to make the viewer feel like they are feeling with the character. For example, when the main character is discovering that he himself is Tyler Durdan and has been imaging someone the whole time, the scene is filmed in a spastic and outrageous manner to make the viewer connect. The film had a lot of great acting and had one of the greatest plots in movie history and I think you got its review spot on.
22. JD Heard 03.13.15 / 9pm

    This movie is truly incredible because of the originality, as well as the extremely unexpected plot twist at the very end. I didn’t enjoy this movie as much as I think I should have though, because of the way people have talked about it and quoted it constantly, it gave this movie some big shoes to fill in order for me to be amazed. The first time I saw this movie I was somewhat disappointed, partially because of the lighting which was horrific throughout the entire movie as well as the plot twist at the end which was really strange and seemingly out of the blue. However, I can also see how some people could really enjoy this movie as it is very well done.
23. Noemi Quinones 06.05.17 / 11am

    Fight club is definitely one of the most intriguing films I’ve watched so far. It keeps you on your toes and you always find a new detail every time you rewatch it. What I found most interesting was Fight Club’s use if setting and lighting to express the protagonist’s decaying mental health. In the beginning of the film we see the protagonist living in a clean, well furnished apartment, located at the top of a building. He earns enough to live on his own and is constantly making new additions to his home. This living space is indicative of a healthy human psyche. However, when the protagonist meets Tyler –who we later find out is only one of his personalities– the setting of his living conditions changes dramatically, mirroring the protagonist’s spiraling psyche. He moves into a dimly lit, condemned building. Although he soon acquires roommates, the cluttered living space, decaying building and poor lighting suggests a change in the protagonist’s mental health.
24. madisonbowman 10.10.17 / 5pm

    Fight Club was definitely a great film that had complimenting actors, and directing techniques that helped compliment the film. A lot of great directing techniques include: cinematography, dark and light shadowing, mis-en-scene, character development, etc.. I agree how clearly hints were dropped throughout the film that were unnoticeable to a new viewer’s eye. We were aware of his insomnia from the beginning, yet never really thought much about it once Tyler showed up. That alongside other hints were made apparent, yet disguised through great plot to leave you ignoring them until the reveal is made at the end of the film. This was a fantastic film that used many techniques to bring it to a new level. It is loved by many and criticized by very few. I enjoyed this film a great deal myself and was very happy to be introduced to it in my film class.
25. cole carouba 10.11.17 / 9am

    When it comes to watching movies, I would have to say that I am a somewhat tough critic. It takes a quality movie to actually draw in my attention. Fight Club has to be hands down one of my favorite movies of all time. The plot itself is masterly laid out, keeping the audience guessing the entire film. The acting is believable to a point where you believe the film is almost a non-fiction. The mise-en-scene ties the film together making it feel like its in its own little world. The shadows and camera angles of the film are the cherry on top, making this film one of the best ever. I thought that you did a good job at concisely describing the film in a way that is understandable to those reading your review without watching the movie.
26. Gregory Kronen 07.21.18 / 10am

    Fight Club is one of those great movies that has us thinking all the way until the end. The production designer and director did a wonderful job designing and giving form to the film, leaving us with subtle hints that lead the audience to the twist at the end. It was interesting when watching this movie because I did not notice the hints at all until the ending happened; that is how subtle they were. The mise-en-scene was also well created, and established a real world feel to the film. The acting, the lighting, the settings all helped create a story that was very intriguing to follow along with; never giving us a dull moment.
27. Cody Atwood 03.09.19 / 1pm

    Fight Club is an extraordinary film. The movie captures my full attention every time I watch it; it’s just that great! This film has always been one of my favorites for a multitude of reasons. The movie offers a variety of different lightings that create a different tone for each character. In my opinion, I found that this established a relationship between the viewer and character which allowed for the film to unfold positively. Also, the storyline presented leaves you in thought. While this film provides many quality attributes, it also leaves you questioning the implications that accompany it, thus making it a spectacular film. After watching this movie with more of a background, it has opened my eyes to all the cinematology that has gone into it. It is entirely amazing. For anyone who enjoys a twisted plot with some action, I recommend giving this movie a watch!
28. igor.haenel 06.08.19 / 7am

    I have also seen this movie a few times and I agree that Fincher made a great movie for us. The editing, the way they built up every single scene and especially the acting. Nearly every scene has a lot to say but in a few different ways. The movie shows us an extended version of what happens to a lot of people everyday. I also love how the creators took it to the next level when more and more people get involved in the ‘movement’, because we can also see the effects on the individuals by joining this group. The whole plot of the movie is just fascinating and I would say it is one of the most interesting movies to watch.
29. Kayla little 06.08.19 / 8am

    Fight Club is one of my favorite movies of all time. It consistently makes you think and I also noticed little clues throughout the movie once the big plot twist was revealed. Each time I watch it, I notice something different. It portrays the human mind and psyche very well, and leaves you feeling like you are in the main characters mind. Each character is very complex and getting to know each one throughout the movie is a thrill. The major plot twist is my favorite part of this movie because the first time you watch it, you can never ever see it coming. No one I know that has watched this movie has been able to predict the ending. It keeps you entertained and on the edge of your seat the whole time.
30. Sarah Grant 06.08.19 / 6pm

    This in my opinion is one of the most clever and interesting films of our time. It truly makes you think of many different important topics in society. I think the writer did a very good job highlighting the mental illness within this film. I agree with you that Fincher created a very well written film for us. I believe the actors in this film fit each role very well, and is part of the reason why this film is such a classic. I also viewed the fight club and a terrorist organization, or a cult. I don’t think this is what anybody in the fight club saw coming, it seemed to have gotten way larger than they could grasp.
31. Jonna Wallin 06.18.19 / 8am

    I found Fight Club so interesting that I decided to write my term paper for Film Studies 101 on this film. Not only is the story great and the narrative very interesting, the editing techniques used in Fight Club will also be great to analyze and write about. I agree that this movie really makes you think, and if a movie does that I also think it is successful.
32. Cole Gardner 10.16.19 / 1pm

    Fight Club is an interesting movie that keep the viewers thinking all the way till the end. I loved the movie because it portrayed the characters illness very well and it showed a connection between a large pallet of people that were all searching for the “thrill” or something new that fight club was. Fight Club fulfilled these peoples boring repetitive lives, dead end jobs, and desk jobs that ultimately helped them relive stress physically, and mentally. The Fight Club review above does a very good job of summarizing to the point, the films key parts and turning points. The analysis of Brad Pitt and Edward Norton “Contradicting” each other is spot on.
33. Isaac Brooks-Church 10.18.19 / 9pm

    . Fight Club is an excellent movie that gets progressively more interesting the more you watch. As you mentioned there are many small hints towards the final twist throughout. This is partly what makes the film such a good re-watch. For example when the main character calls Tyler Durden after his apartment blows up he is first greeted by a dial tone. However Tyler calls him back moments after on the pay phone that clearly says it cannot get calls back. Another instance is when they magically switch seats during the car crash scene. Overall this movie is very deep and Fincher really shows off his attention to detail throughout.
34. Jessenia Robledo 11.22.19 / 10am

    Fight Club was a one of those films that keeps the audience captivated throughout. I really enjoyed the film because of the raw message it delivered about the issues in society. I agree with the analysis you made about Brad Pitt and Edward Norton “contradicting”each other. Tyler Durben was used to showcase the state of mind of the unnamed narrator and possessing all the qualities the unnamed narrator felt that he lacked.
35. Shashank Thattai 11.22.19 / 7pm

    This is one of those movies where the visual style (colours / lighting / mis-en-scene) all match with the theme of the movie. The light colors match the mood of the characters, blended very well. The cinematography and the editing are mixed very well in many scenes – example the one where the narrator is beaten up to the extent that his face is disfigured. Camera angles from low position – beneath the main character, making the audience look up making the character bigger(larger), thus making the character more threatening and powerful. There are many reaction shots of the crowd watching the fight so that viewers can connect with the aggression on the screen. The various techniques mixed together makes this as one of the finest films despite the violence in the film.
36. Karina De La Mora 03.05.20 / 8am

    The movie’s ability to make you think is something I highly admired as well. The complexity of the movie was shown not only through the 2 opposing characters but through the camera angles and lighting that was used in certain scenes. Specifically the fight scenes, the camera angle would switch from high to low very often. The different lighting in scenes promote the way a character is feeling at that time, making the viewer feel it too. Most of the movie is gloomy, filled with shadows and darkness, which is exactly how the main character feels. The over all design of the movie really helped convey the complicated plot of the film.
37. Jeffrey Van Horn 07.18.20 / 2pm

    I think Fight Club is an amazing movie. I had just seen it for the second time in my life, the first time I was too young to remember much. I never realized how much thought was put into this movie as a kid. I just thought it was a movie about fighting, never really understanding the ending. Even now after reading all of the comments, there are so many little things I missed throughout this film, it makes me just want to go watch it again. I never noticed that they never say Edward Nortins characters real name. David Fletcher did an amazing job on this film from the lighting and the overall tone of the film could not have been done any better in my opinion.
38. Jorja Moes 10.23.20 / 3pm

    I COULDN’T AGREE MORE. You know a movie has done it’s job when you are kept at the edge of you seat for the movie in it’s entirety, until the very end when everything comes together in understanding, and leaves you with an epic message. There are so many elements to this movie that symbolize insomnia; but the audience only comes to appreciate its purpose in the end when it’s revealed (spoiler) that the entire plot of the movie was merely aftermath of Tyler imagining things. It’s visual effects of lighting, costume design, and set design all work together to effectively portray this dream-state that is so wonderfully encouraging to the overall purpose of the film. Needless to say, you need to see this movie…it’s amazing!
39. Samantha Fabian 11.05.20 / 9am

    After watching Fight Club for my film class, I just had to add it to my favorites list. I couldn’t agree more about this film being both stunning (it’s lighting is gorgeous) and amazing. If I could watch Fight Club again for the first time, I would in a heartbeat. You are right in saying that this film makes you think nonstop, it’s constantly adding new elements that make you question both the character and the writing, only for everything to come together at the end along with that certain plot twist. The entire set design within the film also drew my attention, whether they filmed in a real city scape or not, they had to decide what was and wasn’t on camera and the scenery melded together greatly. Fight Club truly is an amazing film!
40. Samantha Fabian 11.05.20 / 9am

    After watching Fight Club for my film class, I just had to add it to my favorites list. I couldn’t agree more about this film being both stunning (it’s lighting is gorgeous) and amazing. If I could watch Fight Club again for the first time, I would in a heartbeat. You are right in saying that this film makes you think nonstop, it’s constantly adding new elements that make you question both the character and the writing, only for everything to come together at the end along with that certain plot twist. The entire set design within the film also drew my attention, whether they filmed in a real city scape or not, they had to decide what was and wasn’t on camera and the scenery melded together greatly.
41. Sidney Stalie 03.05.21 / 7pm

    This movie was so much deeper than I thought it would be, it was a very good movie and the narrative made me think it was much more fascinating. I liked how there were many turning points in this film, there were many dimensions to the film in my opinion. In most of the film, the audience thinks the plot is one thing and I had not suspected the sudden switch of the storyline, along with the different conflicts the protagonist dealt with there were many levels to the film that all fit together in the end. Just like the author of this entry pointed out, there were subtle hits that showed the plot twist of the film early on.
42. Phoenix Sudaria 03.28.21 / 6pm

    I agree about Fincher taking the insomnia to an elevated level. Because of the insomnia, he meets Tyler. Tyler is what the narrator wants to be; his alter ego. But it’s deeper than that, its not only who he wants to be, its how he wants to be seen as. He admires Tyler. Fight club members think of him as the sole leader and the narrator is jealous of that. We hear him express that in diegetic and non-diegetic sound. “In Tyler we trust,” when the narrator says this its meant to show us what the narrator thinks of Tyler and how others view him. He also expresses his jealousy diegetically when he explains to Tyler that he is also an equal leader in the fight club.
43. Adela Figueroa 10.14.21 / 5pm

    I couldn’t agree with you more on this one! I am a big fan of this movie. After I watched Fight Club for the first time, I literally wanted to watch it again right after. The movie depicts insomnia and mental health in such an interesting and complex way. It is incredibly well written, in a way that subtly hints at the true events occurring throughout the movie, without revealing anything until the very end. This filming decision literally created the story, creating one narrative of which the viewer would follow, later presenting the true narrative, which reveals the meanings and themes throughout the movie.
44. Stan Pearlman 10.23.21 / 1pm

    I agree this film keeps you thinking throughout the whole film which I really enjoyed. There seems to be more issues than insomnia going on in the narrator’s head, its almost like he has a multiple personality disorder because he isn’t always sleep deprived when Tyler Durden is around. I thought the twist was great and I agree the movie is so good because it makes you think of all the previous scenes where the narrator’s personality of Tyler Durden shows up, and how he interacts with others during those scenes. I also thought that this film was written very well and can’t think of anything to change that would make the film better.
45. Emily Lash 11.10.21 / 5pm

    “Fight Club” is by far one of the greatest films I have seen. There is so much depth to its narrative and the characters are constructed absolutely marvelously. I found this film’s depiction and utilization of psychological elements to be extremely compelling. Specifically, I rather enjoyed the director’s use of dissociative identity disorder as a plot device. Overall, this film caught me completely off-guard and the ending left me pleasantly stupefied. I would describe “Fight Club” as a gift that keeps on giving, because once you think you’ve got the film figured out, it throws you a curveball that makes you fall in love with it even more.
46. Norah Bajari 06.04.22 / 11pm

    I totally agree that Fight Club is meant to make you think. I like how you called attention to the way Norton and Pitt compliment one another. They are foil character for clear reasons. Throughout the film I thought that Norton’s character was infatuated with the idea of Tyler Durden. He wished he could be like him and followed him to a T. The twist is wild and it is interesting to think back on the movie and how the twist holds up. An unreliable narrator makes you question everything and the ending is rather interesting because we do not know what is real and what is not. Who really is Norton’s character? Is that him in the after life since the bullet healed so fast and it seemed like everything happened really quickly? these are questions we are meant to think s about, but will never. Really know the true answer to. It is a brilliantly done movie and it sure accomplishes creating feelings of discomfort. It is a hard movie to watch. In a way it compares to the existentially dreadful feeling of watching an environmental documentary that ends on the note of how the world is going to end.
47. Jude Smit 09.05.22 / 8pm

    Fight Club is one of the greatest films I have ever seen. There is so much about this movie that makes it great in my eyes. The creative story, characters, plot, way its filmed, and most importantly, its twist. Throughout the film I thought Edward Norton was a wannabe who just wanted to be Tyler Durden, wishing he had the balls, talent, and looks Tyler had. When I found out Norton was Durden, and this movie had an unreliable narrator, it just blew my mind. An unreliable narrator is one of the best ways to tell a story, in my opinion, as you can never tell what is going on. I recommend everyone see this movie at least once in their lives!
48. Denise Tovar 09.11.22 / 11am

    I agree that this movie makes one think of it “nonstop.” After watching Fight Club I kept rethinking scenes from the beginning which gave us clues to the big plot twist. For example, he would say things like,“Sometimes Tyler spoke for me” and “Tyler’s words coming out of my mouth.” Another thing I noticed when looking back in the film is the design and mise-en-scène. Tyler and Marla dress very similarly, with the leather jacket and spiked up hair. Not only that but they’re attitudes are similar. This amkes me wonder if Marla was also part of his imagination, which would make sense. Overall, I agree that it is a great movie !
49. Marcel Armstrong 10.17.23 / 11am

    Fight club has to be one of my favorite movies. Throughout the entire movie you’re eager to know what happens next and even just what’s happening in general. The mise en scène created by the director pulls you further into the film and does extremely well at keeping you in a slight state of adrenaline because of the high energy, eerie, and some times gruesome scenes. I really liked how you pointed out that this movie highlights the affects of insomnia and how this all occured due to the narrators weakened mental state.

Home | SBCC | Class Schedule | Film and Media Studies

Contact: Prof. Nico MaestuCopyright 2007-23 Log in